9 Warning Signs You Are Suffering from Toxic Productivity

April 4, 2023

If you’re a driven leader, chances are you are constantly pushing yourself to hit new goals, produce more, and become more efficient. But what many leaders fail to realize is that your intense drive can easily slide into toxic productivity.


Don’t get me wrong, much of your drive is admirable. After all, having worthy work is one of the leading attributes of a life of significance. Your life and leadership improve significantly when you become more efficient, productive, and organized.


But too much of a good thing can become a bad thing. Even productivity can turn toxic.

check engine light

As much as I’m a student of Higher Performance (this is my lifework, and I lead a national institute for campus teams each quarter that’s helped hundreds of leaders become more productive), taken to its extreme, productivity becomes counter-productive.


There’s a point at which applying the strategies, tactics, and tips associated with productivity can make a good thing go bad. Sometimes with devastating consequences.


It’s ironic, but hyper-productive people with toxic efficiency experience the same overwhelm that disorganized people do.


Toxic productivity can also lead to burnout, which no leader wants. (Here are
5 Very Real Reasons Campus Leaders are in Such a Pressure Cooker Right Now).


9 Warning Signs You’re Suffering from Toxic Productivity


Toxic productivity is a trap. You think you’ll solve problems, but over-applying productivity strategies makes you more stressed, not less.


So how do you know whether your fascination with productivity is turning toxic?


Here are nine warning signs that you’re starting to suffer from toxic productivity.


1. You Can’t Turn It Off


As the burnout epidemic has been made evident repeatedly, leaders who never take a break end up breaking.


One sign that your obsession with productivity is counter-productive is that you are unable (or unwilling) to turn it off.


Everything 
in your life has become about being more efficient and more productive.


This means you can end up spending all your waking hours working. The problem is that you were not designed to work all day every day and never get a break.


As this study from the 
American Psychological Association shows, taking breaks makes you more productive and increases both your job and life satisfaction.



Practical Strategies to Reclaim Your Momentum and
Transform Team Performance


Enroll in the Lead Team Institute for the 2023-2024 academic year and Optimize Higher Team Performance.


Lead Team Institute
Enroll in the Lead Team Institute

2. You Have No Hobbies…or a Life


A second sign you’re struggling with toxic productivity is that you have no hobbies, or life for that matter.


Sorry. Taking a break from work to watch Sports Center, Netflix, or YouTube is not a hobby.


By definition, a hobby costs you both time and money. It should also take your full focus, whether your hobby is mountain biking, glass blowing, beer brewing, cross fit, cross stitch, touch rugby, photography, scuba diving, or learning a new language.


You probably don't have one if you can’t answer the question “what’s your hobby” in 3 seconds or less.


Many leaders I serve have no hobbies or life outside of work. And that’s a price not worth paying.


3. You Work Because You Want To. And You Always Want To


To make matters worse for productivity over-achievers, work now follows us everywhere via your phones and laptops.


You used to have to go to the office to do work. Now the office goes to you and with you everywhere you go.


And because you can work, you do.


4. You Know Productivity Shame


For many driven leaders, it’s hard to sit still. But productivity shame goes deeper than that. 


What is productivity shame exactly?


According to 
Rescue Time, productivity shame involves the feeling that you aren’t allowed to do things that are “unproductive.”


You feel guilty when you spend time on hobbies (see above), watch a movie, or simply sit back and relax.


In other words, you're not satisfied if you’re not working. 


5. Your Oasis is Always Three Months Away 


Blank space in your calendar is a trap. It looks like freedom, but its captivity disguised as liberty.


One reason toxic productivity is so deadly is that you can trick yourself into believing it will get better soon. And by soon, you mean three months from now.


For example, you might say to yourself, “
March is madness, but after commencement in May, it is going to be awesome!”


The reason it’s easy to fall for is because when you look three months ahead in your calendar, it seems pretty blank.


The problem is 
that’s precisely what May looked like back in February and what October looks like in July.


And so, we fool ourselves into thinking that relief is three months away. Except it never is.


If you want to access a better way to plan for the future,
here are several resources to help. 


6. Your Closest Relationships Are Suffering


Eventually, you’ll quit or retire from your job. You never retire from being a parent, a spouse, or a good friend.


The people who pay the greatest price for toxic productivity are not your co-workers—they’re the people closest to you: Your spouse, kids, and friends.


You blow them off, tell them to wait, explain that you’re too busy, and bury your head in your laptop.


The people closest to you should have the best access to you. But toxic productivity creates the opposite impact: The people closest to you get the leftovers of you.


7. You’re Always Trying to BEST Yourself


For top performers, work can become a little like how Google Maps has become to many of us: you’re always trying to beat the ETA by just a few minutes.


And once you shave a minute off your arrival time, the gauntlet is set to shave another minute (or two) off to see if you can arrive even faster (I’m speaking hypothetically here).


Productivity turns toxic when you’re unsatisfied with your progress or results.

It always has to be a little faster, better, and always up and to the right.


What’s worse, this kind of behavior gets rewarded.


Workaholism is the most rewarded addiction in America. If you drink too much, you get fired. If you work too much, you get a raise and promotion.


8. There’s No Finish Line


If you don’t declare a finish line to your work, eventually, your body will. It’s called burnout.


As noted, the challenge with productivity is that you can always get better.


You can always become a little more efficient, a little more effective, download a new app, or master a new skill that helps you get a little more done in less time, which creates more time for more work.


Which means there’s no finish line. Ever.


Every piece you wrote could be a little better. Every day you spend could have been a little more ideal.


As leaders who have burned out know, though, if you don’t declare a finish line to your work. Eventually, you will burn out.


9. You’re Overwhelmed, But That’s Normal


Healthy productivity has a finish line and leads to a life of peace, not just a full work schedule.

It allows you to sleep at night, take a real vacation, work out, make time for hobbies, friends, and family, and still get much more done at work.


Toxic productivity never leaves you feeling satisfied. It leaves you feeling overwhelmed.


Semester II is when you start planning for Semester I


This is one of the best opportunities to begin planning to accelerate your team’s performance.


I have had the pleasure of serving school district, and college campus Lead Teams for the past decade and know your system's performance is directly connected to this team's health (and smarts).


❓How’s your team’s communication and connection?
❓How’s the quality of your system’s alignment and execution?
❓What’s your plan for optimizing your Lead Team’s capacity?


As THE people leader for your system, I invite you and your leadership team to consider enrolling in the Lead Team Institute {LTI} for the 2023-2024 academic year.

Here is a quick link for more info.


This national initiative is designed to Optimize Higher Team Performance:


✅ Team Communication
✅ Team Connection
✅ Team Alignment
✅ Team Execution
✅ Team Capacity
✅ Reliable Systems


Our fall kickoff dates are filling up. Schedule your preferred fall kick-off date here.


Ready to reclaim your momentum and optimize Higher Team Performance?


Get Access Today. 


Dr. Joe Hill - Founder, Higher Performance Group


“Because everyone deserves to live in a community served by healthy teams and highly reliable systems.”

More Blog Articles

By HPG Info February 19, 2025
What fruit flies and frustrated executives have in common Picture this: A minor workplace irritant shows up in your inbox at 8:47 AM. By lunch, it's festered into a full-blown emotional abscess. Sound familiar? You're not alone - and the science behind this emotional contagion is more fascinating than you'd think. Recent research in organizational psychology reveals that leader annoyance acts like an emotional pathogen, spreading through teams with surprising speed and potency. A groundbreaking study by Barsade and O'Neill (2016) found that emotional contagion from leaders to team members occurs in as little as seven minutes of interaction. The kicker? Negative emotions spread faster than positive ones by a factor of 3:1. The Neural Network of Negativity Just as our bodies respond to physical injuries with inflammation - a protective response gone awry - our brains process minor emotional injuries through a similar mechanism. Neuroscience research by Davidson et al. (2019) demonstrates that sustained irritation activates the same neural pathways as physical pain, creating what they call an "emotional inflammatory response." The real danger isn't in the initial trigger. It's in what organizational behavior expert Susan David calls the "emotional amplification loop." When leaders marinate in their annoyance, they unknowingly give permission for their entire team to do the same. The Numbers Tell the Story Here's what the research reveals: Teams with chronically annoyed leaders showed a 24% decrease in psychological safety scores (Edmondson & Lei, 2022) Negative emotional expressions from leaders are remembered 4x longer than positive ones One visible display of leader frustration can impact team productivity for up to 4 hours The Emotional Composting Method Here's the pivot point: While we can't control the initial emotional paper cut, we absolutely own what happens next. David's research makes a crucial distinction between sharing our "wounds" (raw, current irritations) and our "scars" (processed, learned-from experiences). The former spreads contagion; the latter builds resilience. The most emotionally intelligent leaders I know have developed what I call an "annoyance off-ramp" - a practiced response to those first tingles of irritation. They've learned to metabolize minor frustrations before they become major infections. Think of it as emotional composting - turning what could be toxic waste into fertilizer for growth. Three Practices for Emotional Composting Name it to tame it: Label your irritation specifically and privately Track your emotional inflammation rate: How quickly do minor annoyances escalate? Create your personal off-ramp ritual: A specific practice for processing irritation Your Leadership Challenge Gather your leadership team and pose this question: "What's our team's current 'emotional inflammation rate'? If we tracked how quickly minor annoyances escalate into team-wide issues, what patterns would we see?" Identify one specific friction point from the past month and map out how it spread through your organization. What could an "annoyance off-ramp" look like for that particular situation? Remember: Culture isn't just what you celebrate - it's what you tolerate. Including your own emotional reactions. REFERENCES : Barsade, S. G., & O'Neill, O. A. (2016). Manage your emotional culture. Harvard Business Review, 94(1), 58-66. Davidson, R. J., et al. (2019). The neural bases of emotional regulation. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 20(11), 563-572. Edmondson, A. C., & Lei, Z. (2022). Psychological safety: The history, renaissance, and future of an interpersonal construct. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 9, 233-261.
By HPG Info February 11, 2025
Strategies for Moving Past Organizational Gridlock When problems become our pets, we feed them daily. We house them in the corners of our institutions, letting them grow from minor inconveniences into immovable monuments. As educational leaders, we're particularly susceptible to this trap - not because we're ineffective, but precisely because we're busy and dedicated to getting things right. The psychology behind problem hoarding is fascinating. Research by Sheard and Kakabadse (2022) found that educational leaders often develop what they term "complexity attachment" - an unconscious investment in maintaining difficult situations rather than resolving them. This manifests in behaviors like refusing support, rejecting collaboration, and personalizing institutional challenges. The Hidden Cost of Holding On Studies reveal alarming statistics: 65% of educational leaders report spending more than half their time managing recurring problems Teams under problem-hoarding leadership show 41% lower innovation rates Institutional change initiatives fail 73% more often when leaders refuse to delegate challenges Breaking Free: The Three R's of Problem Liberation Release : Acknowledge that holding problems doesn't equal solving them Redistribute : Share challenges across your team's collective wisdom Reimagine : View problems as opportunities for systemic growth The Power of Productive Detachment Recent work by Heifetz and Linsky (2021) suggests that leaders who practice "productive detachment" show significantly higher rates of successful organizational transformation. This means: Separating personal identity from institutional challenges Creating space for multiple solution pathways Embracing collective problem-solving approaches From Hoarding to Harvesting The most effective leaders understand that problem-solving isn't a solitary sport. Fullan's (2023) study of high-performing school districts found that leaders who engaged in "networked improvement communities" solved complex challenges 3.4 times faster than those who tackled issues alone. Your Action Steps Identify one problem you've been "polishing rather than solving" Invite three fresh perspectives to examine the challenge Document the resistance and revelations that emerge Remember: The alternative to problem hoarding isn't problem abandonment - it's problem sharing. References: Edmondson, A. C. (2018). The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Wiley. Fullan, M. (2023). Leading in a culture of change (3rd ed.). Jossey-Bass. Heifetz, R. A., & Linsky, M. (2021). Leadership on the line: Staying alive through the dangers of leading (2nd ed.). Harvard Business Review Press. Sheard, G., & Kakabadse, A. P. (2022). Leadership in turbulent times: A study of organizational adaptation and transformation. Journal of Change Management, 22(1), 45-67.
Show More
Share by: